The Truth Takes a Toll: Why Jonathan Smyth Pays a Price for Every Case
- haleyn4
- Jun 14
- 2 min read

Some detectives solve a crime and move on.Jonathan Smyth doesn’t.
In The Case of the Screaming Tunnel, author Frank F. Fiore builds a world where truth isn’t a triumph—it’s a cost. And Smyth pays it every time.
He doesn’t carry trophies. He carries the weight of what he couldn’t save, what he uncovered, and what he had to leave behind.
What Happens After the Truth Comes Out?
In most mysteries, once the case is closed, the story ends.But Smyth knows better.Because when you rip the lie out of a town, you don’t always leave it better off.
You just leave it honest.
And honesty has a cost. It alienates the people who needed the lie. It hurts the ones who were protecting someone else. And it always, always isolates the man who revealed it.
Smyth accepts this.He doesn’t flinch.But Frank F. Fiore makes sure you feel what it does to him.
The Tunnel Isn’t Just a Crime Scene—It’s a Mirror
The legend of the Screaming Tunnel is comforting. It explains the unexplained.But Smyth sees what others can’t: the town doesn’t need a ghost—it needs a shield. A way to avoid looking inward.
And once he removes that shield?
Guilt rises
History resurfaces
People look at each other differently
Fiore doesn’t write happy endings. He writes necessary ones.
Justice Isn’t the Win—It’s the Weight
Smyth doesn’t ride out smiling. He rides out alone, again.Not because he failed—because he did what no one else would.
Frank F. Fiore shows us that truth, real truth, doesn’t cleanly restore order. It disrupts. It reveals. It burns.
And the man who brought it to light?He’s left to carry the ashes.
Conclusion: Some Men Don’t Just Find the Truth—They Pay for It
Jonathan Smyth isn’t just a cowboy sleuth.He’s a witness.To what justice really feels like.To what honesty costs.
And in Frank F. Fiore’s hands, every case Smyth solves becomes a scar he wears—quietly, completely, and without complaint.
📚 Pick up the book and walk beside the man who solves crimes not for recognition—but because he knows no one else will.🔗 Start reading The Case of the Screaming Tunnel now
Comments